There's a question that comes up in fistula communities more than almost any other, and it almost never gets asked directly. It gets asked sideways, buried in a longer post, or typed out at 2 AM in a throwaway account. The question is some version of: who is going to want me like this?

If you've thought it, you're not alone. I spend a lot of time in these forums and communities, and the worry about dating, relationships, and sex runs underneath a huge amount of what people post. So instead of pretending I have all the answers, here's what actually comes up over and over from people living it.

Important: This content reflects personal experience and community-sourced tips, not medical advice. Every fistula case is different. Always discuss treatment decisions, including when it's safe to resume sexual activity, with your colorectal surgeon or gastroenterologist. What worked for one person may not be right for your situation.

The Fear Is Almost Always Bigger Than the Reality

This is the single most common thread. People spend weeks or months convinced that the fistula, the seton, the drainage, the scarring, makes them unlovable or undatable. Then they actually have the conversation with a partner, and the partner's reaction is some version of "okay, what do we need to do about it?"

Not always. But far more often than the fear predicts. The people who report back after dreading the conversation usually say the same thing: it went better than I thought. The story they'd built in their head was worse than anything the other person actually felt.

That doesn't make the fear stupid. It makes sense. But it's worth knowing that the people on the other side of that conversation rarely describe the disaster everyone braces for.

Telling an Existing Partner

For people already in a relationship when this hits, the recurring theme is that the strain is real but survivable, and that hiding it makes everything worse.

A seton is a thin loop your surgeon threads through the fistula tract to keep it draining. It's there for months sometimes. You cannot really hide months of sitz baths, gauze, drainage, and surgeries from someone you live with, and the people who try usually end up more isolated and more anxious for it.

What comes up again and again is that partners handle the logistics better than the patient expects, and that the harder part is the emotional side: the patient pulling away, feeling unattractive, snapping from the stress, going quiet. The condition itself is rarely what damages the relationship. The withdrawal and shame around it does more harm.

Pro tip: The advice that gets repeated most is to tell your partner what you need, not just what's wrong. "I'm dealing with this and I feel disgusting and I need you to be patient with me" lands very differently than going silent and hoping they don't notice.

Dating Someone New: When Do You Tell Them?

This is the big debate, and there's no clean consensus. The disclosure-timing question splits people roughly into camps.

Some say tell them early, before things get physical, so nobody's blindsided and you're not carrying a secret. Others say it's nobody's business until things get serious enough that it's relevant, the same way you wouldn't lead with any other private medical thing on a first date.

The middle position, and the one that seems to settle most arguments, is: you don't owe anyone your medical history on date one, but if things are heading toward intimacy, that's the moment to be honest. Not a dramatic confession. Just a calm heads-up that you're dealing with a recovery thing and here's what that means in practice.

People who've done it report that the framing matters more than the timing. Matter-of-fact and confident tends to be met with the same. Apologetic and ashamed invites the other person to treat it as a bigger deal than it is.

Intimacy and Sex With a Seton or During Recovery

Here's the part nobody else will talk about plainly, so let's actually talk about it.

The recurring questions are some version of: can I have sex with a seton in? Will it hurt? Will they feel it? What about drainage? When is it safe after surgery?

What people report:

• Timing after surgery is a real thing to clear with your surgeon. This is the one genuinely medical piece. People are told different windows depending on the procedure, and pushing it too early is a common regret. Ask your surgeon directly. It's an awkward question they've heard a thousand times.
• A seton doesn't make intimacy impossible, but it changes the logistics. People mention being self-conscious about a partner feeling the loop, about drainage, about odor. The practical workarounds that come up are timing intimacy around a fresh sitz bath and clean gauze, and being upfront so a partner isn't startled by something they weren't expecting.
• The mental block is usually bigger than the physical one. A lot of people describe being physically able but mentally checked out, too anxious or self-conscious to be present. That tracks with how much anxiety and low mood ride along with this condition.
• Communication does the heavy lifting. The reports that go well almost always involve a partner who's been told what's going on and isn't guessing.

It's not all tidy. Some people go through long stretches with no interest at all, between the discomfort, the anxiety, and the meds. That's also normal and comes up constantly. Libido tends to come back as healing progresses and the stress eases.

Pro tip: The most repeated practical tip is simple. Do your hygiene routine first, and tell your partner what to expect. Both remove the two things people fear most in the moment: a surprise and a scramble.

The Single People

The posts that are hardest to read come from single people who've decided they can't date at all until this is fully resolved, which for some is years away.

The honest range here: some choose to pause dating during the worst stretches and feel fine about it. Others realize they've used the fistula as a reason to isolate, and that the loneliness ended up being heavier than the condition. There's no right answer, but the people who waited until they were "fixed" before letting anyone close sometimes regret how long they put life on hold for a timeline that kept moving.

When It Doesn't Work Out

It would be dishonest to pretend every relationship survives this. Some don't. People do post about partners who couldn't handle it, or relationships that were already strained and broke under the added weight.

What's worth saying: when a relationship ends over a chronic health condition, the condition is usually the thing that revealed a crack that was already there, not the thing that caused it. Cold comfort in the moment. But the people a year out rarely frame it as "the fistula ruined my relationship." They frame it as "I found out who was actually in it with me."

The Throughline

Across all of it, the same point keeps surfacing: the shame is the real obstacle, more than the fistula, the seton, or the drainage. The condition is manageable. The story you tell yourself about being disgusting or unlovable is what shuts down the dating, the honesty, and the intimacy.

You're a person dealing with a hard medical situation. That's it. The people worth your time will see it that way too.

What to Read Next

• The Mental Health Side of Fistula Recovery — the shame and anxiety underneath all of this.
• Living with a Seton: The Long Game — the daily reality of life with a seton in.

Want honest takes on the stuff nobody else covers, sent to you as they go up? Subscribe for new guides.